Patron-Driven Acquisition and the Educational Mission of the Academic Library
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5860/lrts.56n3.199Abstract
Patron-driven acquisition (PDA), also known as demand-driven acquisition, patron-initiated purchasing, or books on demand, allows patrons to select and purchase books for the library collection without staff mediation or oversight. This essay presents the argument that PDA programs are unlikely to improve the quality of academic library collections. In particular, they risk failing to distinguish between students’ immediate desires and their long-term educational needs, making poor use of librarians’ knowledge and expertise, failing to represent the full range of library stakeholders, and producing collections that are biased or poorly balanced. Although PDA can lead to efficiencies in information delivery, those efficiencies do not necessarily support the broader educational goals of the academic library.
References
Robert Neville, James Williams , Caroline C Hunt, '"Faculty-Library Teamwork in Book Ordering,"' College & Research Libraries 59 no. 6 (): 523-32n"Educational mission," in this context, refers to the central goals of the university as a whole: the instruction of students and the successful completion of scholarly projects. See, for example, Boyer, Ernest L,
Scholarship Reconsidered: Priorities
of the Professoriate San Francisco: Jossey-Bass 1990Although institutions such as seminaries and military colleges have additional primary goals, this discussion centers on the goals that are common to nearly all four-year colleges and universities. Libraries support the educational mission of the university to the extent that their programs and services directly affect students’ academic performance and the faculty's scholarly work.nDracine Hodges, Cyndi Preston, Marsha J Hamilton, '"Patron-Initiated Collection Development: Progress of a Paradigm Shift,"' Collection Management 35 no. 3/4 (2010): 208-21 The data for Ohio State University in table 2 refer to the first of the two e-book programs described by Hodges, Preston, and Hamilton.nKristine J Anderson, '"Liberal Arts Books on Demand: A Decade of Patron-Driven Collection Development, Part 1,"' Collection Management 35 no. 3/4 (2010): 125–41 Marianne Stowell Bracke, "Science and Technology Books on Demand: A Decade of Patron-Driven Collection Development, Part 2,"
Collection Management
,no. 3/4 (2010):142–50.nJonathan Nabe, Andrea Imre, Sanjeet Mann, '"Let the Patron Drive: Purchase on Demand of E-Books,"' Serials Librarian 60 no. 1 (2011): 193-97nMichael Levine-Clark, '"Developing a Multiformat Demand-Driven Acquisition Model,"' Collection Management 35 no. 3/4 (2010): 201-7nSteven Carrico, Michelle Leonard, '"Patron-Driven Acquisitions and Collection Building Initiatives at UF,"' Florida Libraries 54 no. 1 (): 14-17nHope Barton, 'Give ’Em What They Want: Patron-Driven Collection Development' () (presentation at Charleston Conference, November 4, 2010), nGail Herrera, Judy Greenwood, '"Patron-Initiated Purchasing: Evaluating Criteria and Workflows,"' Journal of Interlibrary Loan, Document Delivery & Electronic Reserves 21 no. 1/2 (2011): 9-24nDavid C Tyler, '"Just How Right Are the Customers? An Analysis of the Relative Performance of Patron-Initiated Interlibrary Loan Monograph Purchases,"' Collection Management 35 no. 3/4 (2010): 162-79nSusan Macicak, Lindsey E Schell, '"Patron-Driven, Librarian-Approved: A Pay-Per-View Model for E-Books,"' Serials 22 no. 3, Supplement (): 31-38nPeter Spitzform, '"Patron-Driven Acquisition: Collecting as if Money and Space Mean Something,"' Against the Grain 23 no. 3 (): 20nSteve Sharp, Sarah Thompson, '"‘Just in Case’ vs. ‘Just in Time’: E-Book Purchasing Models,"' Serials 23 no. 3 (): 201-6nDracine Hodges, Cyndi Preston, Marsha J Hamilton, '"Resolving the Challenge of E-Books,"' Collection Management 35 no. 3/4 (2010): 196-200nJennifer Perdue, Jan A. Van Fleet, '"Borrow or Buy? Cost-Effective Delivery of Monographs,"' Journal of Interlibrary Loan, Document Delivery & Information Supply 9 no. 4 (1999): 19-28n Advanced Technology Libraries 39 no. 11 (): Nov. 2010nHodges, Preston, and Hamilton, "Resolving the Challenge."nCarol Tenopir, '"New Directions for Collections,"' Library Journal 135 no. 10 (): 24 June 1,2010nJanet R Cottrell, '"What Are We Doing Here, Anyway? Tying Academic Library Goals to Institutional Mission,"' College & Research Libraries News 72 no. 9 (): 516-20nMegan Oakleaf, '"Are They Learning? Are We? Learning Outcomes and the Academic Library,"' Library Quarterly 81 no. 1(Jan. 2011) (): 61-82nIbid., 62–63.nEvelyn Geller, '"The Librarian as Censor,"' Library Journal : 1255-58 Johnson Peggy Introduction to Collection Management and Development," in
Fundamentals of Collection Development and Management
nd ed. Chicago ALA, 2009 1–32.nThaddeus M. Harris, Seleced [sic]
Catalogue of Some of the Most Esteemed Publications in the English Language, Proper to Form a Social Library, With an Introduction Upon the Choice of Books
(Boston: I. Thomas and E.T. Andrews, 1793): ii.nPer O Seglen, '"The Skewness of Science,"' Journal of the American Society for Information Science 43 no. 9 (Oct. 1992) (): 628-38nBarbara Fister, '"Not Sold (Yet) on Ebooks,"' () Inside Higher Ed (Sept. 22, 2011,) nAlison J Head, Michael B Eisenberg, 'Balancing Act: How College Students Manage Technology While in the Library During Crunch Time ' () (Seattle: University of Washington, 2011), nAntonio Valle, '"Multiple Goals, Motivation and Academic Learning,"' British Journal of Educational Psychology 73 no. 1 (March 2003) (): 71-87nGeorge Kingsley Zipf,
Human Behavior and the Principle of Least Effort: An Introduction to Human Ecology
(Cambridge, Mass.: Addison-Wesley, 1949).nMaurice B Line, '"Draft Definitions: Information and Library Needs, Wants, Demands and Uses,"' Aslib Proceedings 26 no. 2 (1974): 87nPia Borlund, '"The Concept of Relevance in IR,"' Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 54 no. 10 (Aug. 2003) (): 913–25 Stefano MizzaroStefano, "Relevance: The Whole History,"
Journal of the American Society for Information Science
, no. 9(Sept. 1997): 810 – 32; Saracevic Tefko, "Relevance: A Review of the Literature and a Framework for Thinking on the Notion in Information Science, Part II: Nature and Manifestations of Relevance,"
Journal of the American Society for Information Science
& Technology 58, no. 13 Nov. 2007 1915 33 Saracevic Tefko, "Relevance: A Review of the Literature and a Framework for Thinking on the Notion in Information Science, Part III: Behavior and Effects of Relevance,"
Journal of the American Society for Information Science
& Technology 58, no. 13 Nov. 2007 2126 – 44 Taylor et al. Arthur R Relationships Between Categories of Relevance Criteria and Stage in Task Completion," Information Processing & Management 43, no. 4 July 2007 1071 – 84nWilliam H Walters, '"Comparative Recall and Precision of Simple and Expert Searches in Google Scholar and Eight Other Databases,"' portal: Libraries and the Academy 11 no. 4 (Oct. 2011) (): 971-1006nAnderson et al., "Liberal Arts Books on Demand," 139.nWilliam H Walters, '"Expertise and Evidence in the Assessment of Library Service Quality,"' Performance Measurement and Metrics 4 no. 3 (2003): 99nLisa Shen, '"Head First into the Patron-Driven Acquisition Pool: A Comparison of Librarian Selections versus Patron Purchases,"' Journal of Electronic Resources Librarianship 23 no. 3 (2011): 203-18nSam Houston State University, 'Sam Houston State University Mini Profile, Fall ' (2011) (Huntsville, Texas: Sam Houston State University, 2011), nAnderson ., "Liberal Arts Books on Demand."nAnderson ., "Liberal Arts Books on Demand"; Bracke, "Science and Technology Books on Demand."nScott A Smith, '"PDA: Driving Off the Cliff or, New Wine in Old Bottles,"' Against the Grain 23 no. 3 (): 40nWilliam H Walters, '"Criteria for Replacing Print Journals with Online Journal Resources: The Importance of Sustainable Access,"' Library Resources & Technical Services 48 no. 4 (Oct. 2004) (): 300-304nTyler et al., "Just How Right Are the Customers?"nIbid., 163.nG. Edward Evans and Margaret Zarnosky Saponaro, Developing Library and Information Center Collections (Westport, Conn.: Libraries Unlimited, 2005): 16nWilliam H Walters, '"A Fund Allocation Formula Based on Demand, Cost, and Supply,"' Library Quarterly 78 no. 3 (July 2008) (): 303–14; Walters William H "A Regression-Based Approach to Library Fund Allocation," Library Resources & Technical Services 51, no. 4 Oct. 2007 263 78nAnderson ., "Liberal Arts Books on Demand," 139.nHerrera and Greenwood, "Patron-Initiated Purchasing."nHodges, Preston, and Hamilton, "Patron-Initiated Collection Development."nDan Hazen, '"Lost in the Cloud: Research Library Collections and Community in the Digital Age,"' Library Resources & Technical Services 55 no. 4 (Oct. 2011) (): 195-204nPolanka, "Patron-Driven Acquisition."nLevine-Clark, '"Developing a Multiformat Demand-Driven Acquisition Model," 205; OCLC,
An eBook Solution for 3,000 Libraries
' () (Dublin, Ohio: OCLC, 2007), nTenopir, "New Directions for Collections."nHodges, Preston, and Hamilton, "Patron-Initiated Collection Development"; Hodges, Preston, and Hamilton, "Resolving the Challenge"; Levine-Clark, "Developing a Multiformat Demand-Driven Acquisition Model"; Nabe, Imre, and Mann, "Let the Patron Drive."nJames A Buczynski, '"Library E-Books: Some Can't Find Them, Others Find Them and Don't Know What They Are,"' Internet Reference Services Quarterly 15 no. 1 (Jan.–Mar. 2010) (): 11–19Herlihy Catherine S and Yi Hua , "E-Books in Academic Libraries: How Does Currency Affect Usage?"
New Library World
, no. 9/102010 371 80nRobert Slater, '"Why Aren't E-Books Gaining More Ground in Academic Libraries? E-Book Use and Perceptions: A Review of Published Literature and Research,"' Journal of Web Librarianship 4 no. 4 (2010): 324nNat Bruning, 'Annual Book Price Update (' () Contoocook, N.H.: YBP Library Services, 2011), nPeter Just, '"Electronic Books in the USA: Their Numbers and Development and a Comparison to Germany,"' Library Hi-Tech 25 no. 1 (2007): 157-64nLeslie Czechowski, '"Problems with E-Books: Suggestions for Publishers,"' Journal of the Medical Library Association 99 no. 3 (): 181–82 Lorbeer Elizabeth and Mitchell Nicole, "eBooks in Academic Health Sciences Libraries,"
Against the Grain
, no. 5 Nov. 2008 30–34.nCzechowski, "Problems with E-Books."nSarah Pomerantz, '"The Availability of E-Books: Examples of Nursing and Business,"' Collection Building 29 no. 1 (2010): 11-14nAl Umut Soydal İrem , and TontaYaşar, "Analysis of E-Book Use: The Case of ebrary, " presentation at 14th International Conference on Electronic Publishing Helsinki, Finland, June 18 2010, http://eprints.rclis.org/handle/10760/14696nSmith, "PDA."nTom Wilkie, Sian Harris, '"E-Books Face Bright Future,"' Research Information no. 46 (Feb./Mar. 2010) (): 9nHodges, Preston, and Hamilton, "Resolving the Challenge," 198nBuczynski, "Library E-Books"; Hodges, Preston, and Hamilton, "Resolving the Challenge."nMichael Hyatt, 'Why Do eBooks Cost So Much?(A Publisher's Perspective),", online posting' () Nov. 2, 2010Hyatt Michael:Intentional Leadership, nNoah Lukeman, 'How Many Copies Must a Book Sell to Be Considered a Success?" online posting, Sept. 8' (2009) Ask a Literary Agent, nBruning, Annual Book Price Update
.nNancy Sprague, Ben Hunter, '"Assessing E-Books: Taking a Closer Look at E-Book Statistics,"' Library Collections, Acquisitions & Technical Services 32 no. 3/4 (Sept. 2008) (): 150-57nChris Armstrong, Ray Lonsdale, '"Challenges in Managing E-Books Collections in UK Academic Libraries,"' Library Collections, Acquisitions, & Technical Services 29 no. 1 (Mar. 2005) (): 33-50nJason S Price, '"Patron Driven Acquisition of Publisher-Hosted Content: Bypassing DRM,"' Against the Grain 23 no. 3 June 2011 (): 16-20 Slater Why Aren't E-Books Gaining More Ground?nNabe, Imre, and Mann, "Let the Patron Drive," 196.nBrad Stone, '"Amazon Erases Two Classics from Kindle,"' New York Times July 18, 2009 (): sec. BnSiriginidi Subba Rao, '"Electronic Books: Their Integration into Library and Information Centers,"' Electronic Library 23 no. 1 (2005): 116-40n'Goldberg Beverly"Librarians Sing the E-Book Blues,"' American Libraries 42 no. 3/4 (): 12 Hadro Josh and Kelley Michael"HarperCollins: 26-Loan Cap on Library Ebooks,"
Library Journal
, no. 6 Apr. 1, 2011 16 18 Macicak and Schell, "Patron-Driven, Librarian-Approved"; Nabe, Imre, and Mann, "Let the Patron Drive."nLynn Silipigni Connaway, Heather L. Wicht, '"What Happened to the E-Book Revolution? The Gradual Integration of E-Books into Academic Libraries,"' Journal of Electronic Publishing () (Fall 2007), nConnaway and Wicht, "What Happened to the E-Book Revolution?"nScott Carlson, '"Online Textbooks Fail to Make the Grade,"' Chronicle of Higher Education 51 no. 23 (Feb. 11, 2005) (): 35–36 Macicak and Schell, "Patron-Driven, Librarian-Approved"; Price, "Patron Driven Acquisition"; Magdalini Vasileiou, Richard Hartley, and Jennifer Rowley, "An Overview of the E-Book Marketplace,"
Online Information Review
, no. 1 (2009) 173–92.nRao, "Electronic Books."nSlater, "Why Aren't E-Books Gaining More Ground?" 305.nJohnson, "Introduction to Collection Management."nValle et al., "Multiple Goals, Motivation and Academic Learning"; Zipf,
Human Behavior and the Principle of Least Effort
.nAt some universities, PDA programs supplement more conventional selection methods. At the University of Denver, for example, the PDA program is intended to replace the slip approval plan; the book approval plan remains in place. Unfortunately, however, most descriptions of PDA programs have not addressed the role of PDA in the library's collection development program.nAnne C Barnhart, '"Want Buy-In? Let Your Students Do the Buying! A Case Study of Course-Integrated Collection Development,"' Collection Management 35 no. 3–4 (2010): 237-43n
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC-BY-NC 4.0) that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) after it has been accepted for publication. Sharing can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.
