Differing Perceptions of Public Librarians and Users in Assessing and Developing Korean Consumer Health Information
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5860/rusq.52.3.3329Abstract
The purpose of this study is to evaluate and compare perceptions between public librarians and public library users and determine their preferences for quality Korean Consumer Health Information (CHI) websites, providing useful data for future CHI resource development and librarian CHI reference services. In this study, a group of librarians and users assessed health information resource sites that are searched by a relatively high number of users, based on the assessment criteria developed in preceding studies. First, there were significant differences between librarian and user groups in assessing health information resource sites, with the user group assessment being more rigorous. Second, the group that participated in criteria development gave higher points than the nonparticipant group in their site assessment. Third, this study analyzed the influence of librarians’ experience in providing, and users’ experience in searching for, health information. Although the differences were not significant, the more experienced groups gave higher points to both sites and criteria assessment than the ones with no experience. Through this study, a total of fifteen health information websites were assessed, and the results can be referred to by both librarians and users in public libraries and applied to other studies on resource assessment in the future. This study is the first study to deal with the assessment of CHI resources available to public librarians and users, as opposed to past studies, which have focused on general Internet users’ assessment of CHI resources. This study is also the first Korean study that has assessed CHI resources available in public libraries.
References
J A Powell, '“A Critical Analysis of the Literature on the Internet and Consumer Health Information, ”' Journal of Telemed Telecare 11 supplement 1 (2005): 41-43nF Susannah, '“Today’s E-patients: Hunters and Gatherers of Health Information Online, ”' () September 2004, accessed August 21, 2011, nM Kerner, '“Teen Use of Web, Online Technologies Growing, ”' () July 27, 2005, accessed August 10, 2011, nS Fox, '“Health Topics: 80% of Internet Users Look for Health Information Online, ”' Pew Internet & American Life Project (2011): accessed July 29, 2012, http://www.pewinternet.org/∼/media//Files/Reports/2011/PIP_Health_Topics.pdfnSee Gunther Eysenbach et al., “Empirical Studies Assessing the Quality of Health Information for Consumers on the World Wide Web: A Systematic Review, ”
JAMA
, no. 20 (2002): 2691–700; Roxanne Cox, Marie A. Reidelbach, and Kate Rose, “Consumer Health Information Resource Service (CHIRS): A Resource for Nebraska, ”
Health Care on the Internet
, no. 4(2002): 37–48; C. Pretlow and C. H. Goldstein, “A Study of Consumer Health Links on Medical School Library Home Page, ”
Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet
, no. 2 (2004): 15–28n'“Consumer Health Information: A Brief Critique on Information Needs and Information Seeking Behaviour, ”' Malaysian Journal of Library & Information Science 6 no. 2 (2001): 83-99nS. Murray, “Consumer Health Information Services in Public Libraries in Canada and the U.S., ”
Journal of the Canadian Health Libraries Association
(2008): 141–43; S. Hindall, “Health Information in Public Libraries in the Netherlands, ”
Scandinavian Public Library Quarterly
, no. 2(2004), accessed August 10, 2011, www.splq.info/issues/vol37_2/09.htmnKyoung-Won Cho, Sin Kam, Young Moon Chae, '“Analysis of Internet Usage Patterns of Health Consumers for Internet Health Information Assessment Criteria, ”' Journal of Korean Society for Health Education and Promotion 4 no. 2 (2007): 15-28 Hoojung Kim and Hyeon-Ae Park, “Selection Criteria and Utilization of Health Information on the Internet by Consumers, ” Journal of the Korean Society of Medical Informatics 10, no. 1(2004): 55–68nSanghee Oh, Younghee Noh, '“Online Health Resource Evaluation Criteria Development: A Case Study of Criteria Rating Comparison between Librarians and Users in Public Libraries in South Korea, ”' LISR 26 (October 31, 2012): www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S074081881200093XnCho, Kam, and Chae, “Analysis of Internet Usage Patterns.”nMustapha Khalil, “Consumer Health Information: A Brief Critique on Information Needs and Information Seeking Behavior, ” MLA, Consumer and Patient Health Information Section; MLA ANNUAL REPORT 2001/02. CAPHIS Annual Report 2001–2002 (MLA, 2001)nJo-Ahn M. Benedetti, “Strategies for Consumer Health Reference Training, ”
Health Care on the Internet
(2002): 63–71; M. L. Gillaspy, “Starting a Consumer Health Information Service in a Public Library, ”
Public Library Quarterly
, no. 3/4(2000): 5–19; Jessica L. Clark, “Consumer Health Staff Training in a Public Library Setting, ”
Journal of Hospital Librarianship
, no. 3(2003): 53–62; N. Calabretta, S. Cavanaugh and B. Swartz, “Growing a Web Page: The Evolution of a Consumer Health Resource, ”
Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet
, no. 3 (2003): 15–34; Martha E. Stone, “Librarian-to-Librarian, ” Journal of Consumer Health On the Internet 8, no. 1 (2004): 1–11; Siobhan Champ-Blackwell and Stephanie Weldon, “Free Online Consumer Health Classes, ”
Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet
, no. 3 (2005): 37–42nA. B. Ruffin et al., “Access to Electronic Health Information for the Public: Analysis of Fifty-Three Funded Projects, ”
Library Trends
, no. 3 (2005): 434–52; F. Wood et al., “Public Library Consumer Health Information Pilot Project: Results of a National Library of Medicine Evaluation, ”
Bulletin of the Medical Library Association
, no. 4(2000): 314–22; C. Scherrer, “HealthWeb: Both a Resource for Public Librarians and a Prototype for Collaboration among Libraries, ”
Public Library Quarterly
, no. 3/4 (2001): 47–51nGuisu Li, '“The Median Age Technique for Assessing Currency of Consumer Health Information Monographic Collections in Public Libraries, ”' Journal of the Medical Library Association 95 no. 1 (2007): 89-90nA Richetelle, '“Healthy Web Sites: Teaching Consumers to Search for Quality Health Information on the Internet, ”' Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet 7 no. 2 (2003): 35-52nOh and Noh, “Online Health Information in South Korean Public Libraries.”nP. C. Rees, “HealthInfoIowa: A Consumer Health Information Web Site for Iowans, ”
Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet
, no. 2 (2004): 29–44; Li, “The Median Age”; J. Burkell and D. J. Campbell, “‘What Does This Mean?’ How Web-based Consumer Health Information Fails to Support Information Seeking In the Pursuit of Informed Consent for Screening Test Decisions, ”
Journal of the Medical Library Association
, no. 3(2005): 363–73; Caryl Gray, “Health and Medical Resources, ”
Journal of Library Administration
, no. 1 (2005): 395–428; L. Hasman and D. Chiarella, “Developing a Pain Management Resource Wiki for Cancer Patients and Their Caregivers, ”
Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet
, no. 4 (2008): 317–26nOh and Noh, “Online Health Information in South Korean Public Libraries.”nIbidnIbidnNoh, Younghee, “An Analyzing of the Current CHI Services in Korean Public Libraries.”nNoh, “An Analyzing of the Current CHI Services in Korean Public Libraries.”n'“A Study of Consumer Health Links on Medical School Library Home Page”; Young-Woon Woo and Kyoung-Won Cho, “Analysis of Confidence and Satisfaction Degrees for Korean Health Information Web-Sites, ”' Journal of the Korea Contents Association 7 no. 3 (2007): 110-17nOh and Noh, “Online Health Information in South Korean Public Libraries.”nIbidnElizabeth Murray, '“The Impact of Health Information on the Internet on Health Care and the Physician-Patient Relationship: National U.S. Survey among 1,050 U.S. Physicians, ”' Journal of Medical Internet Research 5 no. 3 (2003): accessed August 17, 2011, www.jmir.org/2003/3/e17nM Wannarka, '“Medical Collections in Public Libraries of the United States: A Brief Historical Study, ”' Bulletin of the Medical Library Association 56 no. 1 (1968): 1-14nPretlow and Goldstein, “A Study of Consumer Health Links.”nLi, “The Median Age Technique.”nJane Shaddock, '“Appraising the Quality of Consumer Health Information Leaflets, ”' Health Expectations 5 (2002): 84-87nRees, “HealthInfoIowa.”nBurkell and Campbell, “‘What does this mean?’”nD Kovacs, '“Electronic Collection Development for Consumer Health Information, ”' Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet 7 no. 4 (2003): 31-52nHasman and Chiarella, “Developing a Pain Management Resource Wiki.”nGray, “Health and Medical Resources.”nJ M Coggan, '“AARP: Evaluating Health Information on the Internet, ”' Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet 7 no. 4 (2003): 61-66nM Streeter, '“A Pathfinder for Juvenile Diabetes, ”' Public Library Quarterly 18 no. 3/4 (2000): 109-18nMurray et al., “The Impact of Health Information on the Internet.”nWannarka, “Medical Collections in Public Libraries of the United States”; Pretlow and Goldstein, “A Study of Consumer Health Links.”nWannarka, “Medical Collections in Public Libraries of the United States.”nPretlow and Goldstein, “A Study of Consumer Health Links.”nShaddock, “Appraising the Quality of Consumer Health Information Leaflets”; Rees, “HealthInfoIowa”; Burkell and Campbell, “‘What Does This Mean?’”nHasman and Chiarella, “Developing a Pain Management Resource Wiki.”nCoggan, “AARP.”nBurkell and Campbell, “‘What does this mean?’”; Gray, “Health and Medical Resources”; Streeter, “A Pathfinder for Juvenile Diabetes”; Hasman and Chiarella, “Developing a Pain Management Resource Wiki.”nMLA Net, Medical Library Association Task Force on Health Information, “Health Information Literacy: Definitions, ” July 23, 2003, accessed January 24, 2011, www.mlanet.org/resources/healthlit/define.htmlnMLA, “Consumer and Patient Health Information Section.”nJo-Ann M. Benedetti, “Strategies for Consumer Health Reference Training, ”
Health Care on the Internet
(2002): 63–71; Gillaspy, “Starting a Consumer Health Information Service in a Public Library”; Clark, “Consumer Health Staff Training in a Public Library Setting”; Calabretta, Cavanaugh, and Swartz, “Growing a Web Page”; Martha E. Stone, “Librarian-to-Librarian, ”
Journal of Consumer Health On the Internet
, no.1(2004): 1–11; Champ-Blackwell and Weldon, “Free Online Consumer Health Classes.”nR Parker, G L Kreps, '“Library Outreach: Overcoming Health Literacy Challenges, ”' Journal of the Medical Library Association 93 no. 4 (2005): S81-S85 accessed March 15, 2011, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1255757/pdf/i0025-7338-093-04S-0081.pdfnRichetelle, “Healthy Web Sites.”nL Wu, '“Wiring Seniors to Quality Health Information, ”' Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet 10 no. 2 (2006): 11-24nParker and Kreps, “Library Outreach.”nWu et al., “Wiring Seniors to Quality Health Information.”nDiane G Schwartz, '“Seniors Connect: A Partnership for Training between Health Care and Public Libraries, ”' Medical Reference Services Quarterly 21 (2002): 3, 19nSusan LaValley, '“Delaware Health Source: Consumer Health Libraries and Health Literacy Outreach, ”' Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet 13 no. 2 (2009): 180-86nRichetelle, “Healthy Web Sites.”nK H Smith, '“Big Net, Little Pond: Use and Upkeep of Smaller Scope Health Information Sites, ”' Journal of Consumer Health on the Internet 8 no. 1 (2004): 23-40nIbidn
